As the days get cooler, it’s time to embrace the Fall season — not only with how we dress, but also with how we approach our beauty routine. The natural, Autumn-y beauty looks are perfect for working out, lounging by the water with a good book, and picking up that yet-to-bed muffin top. But while doing laundry, you might consider popping some Scotch tape up on your toenails and changing up your manicure to suit your outfit of the day. This is where we come in.

We scoured fashion, beauty, and DIY tutorial sites for ways to instantly transform your toenails into the products you’re about to wear with gusto. We couldn’t help but decide that the tool we needed was polish. We will add that home-made polish is one of the greatest DIY tutorials yet.

Find the best options for you (and whoever happens to be in your apartment) below.

Bucklefish’s sophisticated, $13 version is meant to last 24 hours and is certified cruelty-free.

If you’ve got a willing subject, DIY nail paste is ideal for all occasions. Create your own lacquer to have on hand for all of your Fall festivities. $2 for 3 ounces at Ikea